Skip to main content
Welcome to Sizzle Society™
Steak on a grill with gold flakes.

Sizzle Society

A ButcherBox Rewards Program

A Reward in Every Order

Unbox better benefits, simply by eating better at home

Earn

Earn Points

The more you order the more you earn

Unlock rewards

Unlock Perks

Exclusive perks with each Sizzle Society tier

Insider access

Insider Access

Get early-access to deals, new products and more

Sizzle Society Basics

It couldn't be simpler to sizzle

ShoppingBasket

Shop

Stock up on your favorite products like you always have

Earn 2x points

Earn

Earn 2 sizzle points for every $1 spent. $100 spent = 200 points

Apply points

Apply

100 Points = $1 ButcherBox credit in your account

Featured Perks

Salmon dish being put into the oven.

Free Virtual Cooking Classes

Someone opening up a box.

Annual Anniversary Surprise

Uncooked steak sitting on wooden cutting board.

Exclusive Early Access to New Products

Sizzle Society Tiers

The rewards get even better with each level

Loyalty Tier benefits comparison for points. Column one has a benefit, and the remaining columns represent each loyalty tier and whether it includes that benefit.
Points
Sous Chef Badge

Sous Chef

1—3 Orders

Head Chef

4—10 Orders

Executive Chef

11+ Orders

Earn Points

Checked

Checked

Checked

Redeem Points for Credit

Checked

Checked

Checked

Loyalty Tier benefits comparison for deals and offers. Column one has a benefit, and the remaining columns represent each loyalty tier and whether it includes that benefit.
Deals & Offers

Sous Chef

Head Chef

Executive Chef

Daily Deals

Checked

Checked

Checked

Early Access to Exclusive Deal Days

Checked

Checked

First Access to Exclusive Deal Days

Checked

Early Access to New Products

Checked

Loyalty Tier benefits comparison for extra benefits. Column one has a benefit, and the remaining columns represent each loyalty tier and whether it includes that benefit.
Extras

Sous Chef

Head Chef

Executive Chef

Free Virtual Cooking Classes

Checked

Checked

Checked

Anniversary Surprise

Checked

Checked

Priority Support

Checked

Checked

Swap "Free For a Year" Offer 1x annually

Checked

Checked

Swap "Free For a Year" Offer 3x annually

Checked

Virtual Q&A Series with Our Farmers, Hosted by ButcherBox CEO

Checked

Access to Concierge Assistance

Checked

*Your tier status is based on orders placed in the last 12 months

FAQs - General

Sizzle Society is the ButcherBox Rewards™ program–our way of showing extra appreciation for our members being a part of something better. There’s no need to sign up; all ButcherBox members will begin earning points right away. It’s free, easy, and makes being a ButcherBox member even better.
There’s no need to sign up; all ButcherBox members will begin earning points right away. It’s free, easy, and makes being a ButcherBox member even better.
It sure is! In fact, if you’re a ButcherBox member, you’re already enrolled. What’s better than that?
Although there’s no added cost to be a part of Sizzle Society Rewards, members are free to opt out anytime. Simply email us at support@butcherbox.com.

FAQs - Points

Racking up points couldn’t be easier. Simply order your favorite proteins, like you always have, and you’ll earn 2 points for every $1 spent. Every existing, active member began earning points the day we launched Sizzle Society, October 1, 2024. 
With each ButcherBox order you place, you’ll earn Sizzle Society points. You choose when to redeem your accrued points* for ButcherBox credits which will then be automatically applied to your ButcherBox orders.*Must meet the minimum point amount to redeem for ButcherBox credits (1,000 points).
When you redeem your points*, a credit is added to your account. If the order you’ve applied credit to costs less than the total amount of credit on your account, your additional credit will roll over to your next order.*Must meet the minimum point amount to redeem for ButcherBox credits (1,000 points).
Once you hit 1,000 points ($10 in ButcherBox credits on future ButcherBox subscription purchases), you can start applying credits to your future orders.
As a matter of fact, points don’t play into your Sizzle Society tier. Those are determined based on the amount of orders you’ve placed as a ButcherBox member.
If you do not place an order for 6-months, your tier status and points will reset and you will no longer have access to those tier benefits!

FAQs - Tiers

As long as you’re an active ButcherBox member, one Custom or Curated Box (regular or large) counts as one order. Your tier is calculated based on the number of orders you place in a 12-month period.
  • Sous Chef: 1-3 Orders
  • Head Chef: 4-10 Orders
  • Executive Chef: 11+ Orders
Account access is easy! Simply log in through your member account.
Thanks for being a part of ButcherBox! For existing members, we’ve applied your account activity from the previous year to determine your Tier. Tiers will be recalculated on a rolling 12-month basis. Keep up your orders to up your Tier level!
Welcome to something better! For members who’ve joined after Sizzle Society officially launched, we’ve started calculating your Tier right after you place your first order. Tiers are calculated based on a rolling 12-month period and you have those benefits for the next 12-months.  Your tier is calculated based on the number of orders you place in a 12-month period. See below:
  • Sous Chef: 1-3 Orders
  • Head Chef 4-10 Orders
  • Executive Chef: 11+ Orders
REMINDER: If you go 6 months without placing an order, your tier status will reset and you will lose your tier benefits and points!
If you do not place an order for 6-months, your tier status and points will reset and you will no longer have access to those tier benefits!